Barnett Whitetail Hunter STR vs Whitetail Hunter 2

Barnett Whitetail hunter 2 is one of the best entry level crossbows on the market. How does it compare against something that costs almost double of its price? Are you getting that big of a performance leap? Or should you be satisfied with the Whitetail Hunter 2?

To find out the answer we have to dive deep in the comparison of Barnett Whitetail Pro STR vs Whitetail Hunter 2. Let’s find out which one is the better bang for the bucks.

Barnett Whitetail Hunter STR


Barnett Whitetail Hunter 2

SpecsWhitetail Hunter STRWhitetail Hunter 2
Speed375 FPS350 FPS
Kinetic Energy118.6 FP-KE103 FP-KE
Power Stroke15.7 / 16 Inches12.5 Inches
Draw Weight165 LBS160 LBS
Axle To Axle18.125 Inches16.125 Inches
Length34.875 Inches34.25 Inches
Weight6.6 LBS6.4 LBS

Difference Between Barnett Whitetail Hunter STR & 2

  • Whitetail Hunter 2 is smaller than Whitetail Pro STR.
  • Whitetail Pro STR is more powerful than Whitetail Hunter 2.
  • Hunter 2 is lighter than Whitetail Pro STR.
  • The draw weight is lower on the Whitetail Hunter 2.
  • Whitetail Pro STR is faster. A lot faster.

Those are the noteworthy differences between barnett whitetail hunter str & hunter 2. Now let’s find out which one to choose and why.

Reason To Choose Barnett Whitetail Hunter STR

Barnett Whitetail Pro STR is clearly the more expensive among the two. Why choose this over the cheaper options? By reading the specifications and seeing the differences, you already know this is the better crossbow among the two.

For a little more price, you are getting a faster and more powerful crossbow. Pretty valid reasons to choose this over the Whitetail Hunter 2. It can fire at up to 400 FPS. Which is a lot. Considering how little you are paying for the crossbow, the kinetic energy on this one is also quite good.

Reason To Choose Barnett Whitetail Hunter 2

On paper, the Whitetail Hunter 2 stands no chance against the Whitetail Pro STR. Then why would you choose the “inferior” crossbow? The reasoning is simple. It’s a beginner crossbow that got a lot of things going for it. It has a lower draw weight than the Whitetail Pro STR. It’s also lighter than the Whitetail Pro STR.

The 350 FPS is nothing to make fun of. For a beginner, that’s more than what you need. It’s enough to get you started and land your first hunt.

Cons Of Whitetail Hunter STR

The draw weight on this crossbow is 165 lbs. I know, it’s not the highest you have seen on a crossbow. Granted, you can lower it by 50%. All you need to do is use the included rope cocker. That you should by the way. The included scope could have been better. It’s not that bad. But there are rooms of improvement.

Cons Of Whitetail Hunter 2

For the money, there aren’t many cons of this crossbow. Though I would love to have a more compact crossbow. But that would be pushing it too far. So, no. There aren’t many “cons” of getting this crossbow. This crossbow would have been a blessing to hunters if it was available 10 years ago.

Barnett Whitetail Hunter STR vs II: Video Comparison

Barnett Whitetail Hunter STR vs Whitetail Hunter 2 Summary

To summarize the war between the Barnett Whitetail Pro STR vs Whitetail Hunter 2, you are getting what you are paying for. If you can spend more, then you will get more. If you can’t or don’t want to spend more, you will get enough to be content with. Both of these crossbows are great and I can wholeheartedly suggest them to you guys. No matter which one you go for here, there isn’t a wrong choice. Think of it as a trick question. What do you want?

Leave a Comment